Star City has been closed off by demonic guardians preaching "peace or perish." With the citizens of the city fleeing in terror, the only way to defeat the monsters is with the use of old weapons (or, more specifically, a bow and arrows). While Conner attempts to get the word out not to steal, Ollie tracks down the Riddler to a holding cell and beats the name of his employer out of him. Ollie and Conner track Albert Davis to his mansion in Star City. Unfortunately for them, they also find dozens of demons guarding his house.