Following the events of Titans Tomorrow and Identity Crisis, Starfire has decided to leave the Titans in favor of joining up with the Outsiders and Robin is shutting everyone out about his father being killed by Captain Boomerang. The Titans suddenly get an assignment from the JLA to go to Opal City and look in on the box that Elongated Man first was investigating, one of Luthor's old power suits. There, they meet up with the Electrocutioner, one of Calculator's goons. He makes a smart-alecky remark about Robin's father, causing Tim to go into a blind rage, punching him over and over again. He finally admits that his father was killed and the Titan have an afterschool special moment.
Following the story are two epilogues, pointing towards Luthor's plans for Superboy and Green Arrow's kidnapping by Dr. Light.