May Contest!  |  Add New Content  |  Top Issues  |  Register  |  Marketplace  |  Forums  |  Request a Feature  |  Help  |  Mobile  |  Home


Register for free
Social Media: Facebook Twitter Tumblr

  Search by Cover Date

  Story Arcs
  Public Collections
  Public User Lists

Last 10 titles added:
  1. Itty Bitty Hellboy: The ...
  2. Moon Knight [GER] (2015)
  3. Duck Tales - Jäger der v...
  4. Batman: The Golden Age O...
  5. Just imagine Stan Lee's ...
  6. The Greatest American Co...
  7. The Unauthorized Lampoon...
  8. Political Power: Rush Li...
  9. The Darkness vs. Superma...
  10. Ghostbusters Annual (201...
   View All

Last 10 creators added:
  1. Jacob Hansen
  2. Andreas Raufeisen
  3. Kathy Palin
  4. Rocky Walters
  5. J.B. Fernandes
  6. Andrew Hoffmann
  7. Christian Patchell
  8. Neil Paniry
  9. M. T. Quach
  10. Ian Ally-Seals
   View All

Last 10 characters added:
  1. Strong Guy (Marvel)(Hous...
  2. Hulkling (Marvel)(House ...
  3. Stature (Marvel)(House o...
  4. Miss America (Marvel)(Ho...
  5. Jett (Hercules/Xena)
  6. Loup Noir
  7. Couik
  8. Manitou (Marvel)(02 - de...
  9. Chairman (Top Cow)(Rebir...
  10. Chairwoman (Top Cow)(Reb...
   View All

    Reviews - X-Men: The 198 - #5

View this issue

It's not worth it - ferroboy
I went into the limited series with the idea that it was going somewhere, that there'd be a payoff that would move Decimation forward. Instead, we get butterflies. The series was only mediocre and that's not usually something to keep me reading, unless I anticipate a good resolution.

Throughout the series, I felt that a majority of the 198 (that who weren't X-Men) were written out-of-character, though I admit that Kitty Pryde and Valerie Cooper were perfect. Maybe "out-of-character" is less valid than "one-dimensional". Many of the characters just stood around and looked angry - supposing you could even tell who they were. Caliban started out looking like Wendigo - tall, furry, large ears. Then his ears got shorter but he was still furry. By the end of the series he more-or-less looked like Caliban. It seems obvious Jim Muniz didn't really know who he was drawing but was clued in somewhere along the line.

The problem, though, was the end. Despite the events of the book, we have a somewhat cheery ending and a ridiculous transformation on the part of Mr. M. This series could have left us with a direction in which the mutant survivors were going, even if it was to a much darker place. Instead, we have two characters cheering and smiling on the final page.

I would recommend not reading this.

© 2005-2015 - Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy Special thanks to Brian Wood for the logo design